If you are reading this, there is a good chance you recently received a letter from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) about your mandatory participation in the new Ambulatory Specialty Model (ASM) for heart failure.
CMS has automatically placed about 2,214 cardiologists in 46 states into ASM. Nobody applied, the list came from Medicare claims, and there is no way to opt out. Starting in 2027, Medicare will grade you on the quality of care for your heart failure patients and then raise or cut your pay based on that grade across all your Medicare billing, not just heart failure visits.
Over the past month, our team at SynsorMed has visited more than a dozen independent cardiology practices to talk about this program. Many of the physicians and practice leaders we met had not heard of ASM or understood how much reimbursement is at risk.
This article does three things:
- Explains what the Ambulatory Specialty Model is and who is on the list.
- Breaks down exactly what ASM grades for heart failure.
- Gives you a 5‑minute ASM Readiness Scorecard at the end so you can see whether ASM is more likely to be a pay cut or a pay raise for your practice, and what you can still put in place before January 1.a.
If you only have a few minutes, scroll to the “ASM Readiness Scorecard” section at the end, complete it, and you will have a clear map of next steps for your practice..
What the Ambulatory Specialty Model is
The performance year opens January 1, 2027. Whatever is not running on that date is not counted.
The Ambulatory Specialty Model, or ASM, is a five-year Medicare program that runs from 2027 through 2031. A cardiologist is in it if two things are true:
- They treat enough heart failure patients. They were attributed at least 20 Medicare heart failure episodes a year.
- They practice in a selected area. CMS chose roughly one quarter of the country's metro and micro areas.
CMS posted the final participant list and began sending confirmation letters in September. The final list is shorter than the preliminary one: 393 cardiologists were removed and none were added. If your physicians were on the preliminary list, check the final one. If they are on it, there is no form to fill out, no way to decline, and no way to appeal being included.
What Medicare grades
Each listed cardiologist gets a score from 0 to 100, built from four areas:
- Quality. Five measures: two for heart failure medications in patients with reduced ejection fraction, one for blood pressure control, one for functional status using a standard patient questionnaire (the KCCQ), and one for unplanned cardiovascular hospital admissions. Four of the five count all of a physician's heart failure patients, not just Medicare.
- Cost. What each heart failure episode costs Medicare, compared with peers.
- Care coordination. Two activities must be in place for at least 90 consecutive days during 2027: working with the patient's primary care doctor to complete a required screening, and a signed collaborative care agreement with a primary care practice. Missing one costs 10 points. Missing both costs 20.
- Interoperability. Certified EHR reporting for 180 days of the year, with no hardship exception.
None of these are billing tasks. Your billing company cannot do them, and your EHR does not do them automatically.
What is at stake
The 2027 grade is paid out in 2029, at up to 9 percent up or down. The maximum rises to 10 percent for 2028, 11 percent for 2029, and 12 percent for 2030 and 2031.
The part that surprises people: the adjustment is not limited to heart failure care. It applies to everything that physician bills to Original Medicare Part B that year. Office visits, echocardiograms, stress tests, all of it.
Our view
CMS is grading the right things. Heart failure patients do better when they are on the right medications, when their blood pressure is controlled, and when someone checks on them between visits. We have no argument with the measures.
Where we disagree is how the money works. Bonuses are paid out of penalties, and CMS returns only 85 percent of what it collects. Across the program, more is taken out than paid back. The practices most at risk are small independent groups, which carry the same reporting work as a health system with a fraction of the staff. CMS gives small practices bonus points, but bonus points do not run a care coordination workflow.
So here is what we recommend cardiology practices do about it.
1Reaching every heart failure patient between visits
Four of the five quality measures count every heart failure patient, so a program that only covers Medicare patients leaves most of the score to chance.
- Every patient, regardless of insurance. We recommend enrolling the practice's full heart failure population.
- Partner with a third-party clinician team to help you flag which patients need a clinician.
2Capturing what the measures grade
We recommend recording blood pressure readings, confirming medications, and giving the KCCQ questionnaire at the start and again within the follow-up window. All of it is documented in the chart in a form that counts at reporting time. If it is not in the chart, it did not happen.
3Calling patients after a hospital stay
Call patients within 48 hours of a hospital discharge, when the risk of going back is highest. One of the five quality measures is unplanned cardiovascular admissions, and the cost score follows the same patients.
We recommend not working with any organization that promises a positive score. When bonuses are paid out of penalties, nobody can honestly promise that. We also recommend using your current EHR and billing company to help gather some of this information. But you may need a third party to do the work between visits that this program grades.
Are you prepared?
If you are a practice
Complete the ASM Readiness Scorecard below. You answer ten yes-or-no questions, which takes about five minutes. You get an estimate of what is at risk for your physicians and a Next Steps Map of the gaps to close before January 1.
ASM Readiness Scorecard
Enter your information below to get an ASM Readiness Scorecard Next Steps Map sent to your inbox.
Your answers are used only to generate your Scorecard and to prepare for your review if you book one. They are not shared or sold.
Your revenue at risk
Two inputs. We apply the adjustment rates CMS published in 42 CFR 512.745.
Not sure? Search their NPIs on the CMS site, then come back.
Professional services only. Exclude technical components of imaging and any facility billing. If they vary, pick the higher band.
Your readiness
Answer for the practice as it operates today, not what is planned.
Your ASM Scorecard
Five-year cumulative at maximum:
Quality domains missing:
Your answers
Walk through these results with us
Fifteen minutes. We confirm your physicians on the CMS list, turn the range into a real number with your billing data, and tell you what to fix first.
ASM is budget neutral. The adjustment can be positive or negative and is set relative to the other cardiologists in your cohort. Revenue-at-risk figures are maximum downside on the band you selected, not a forecast. The Readiness Scorecard is a self-assessment based on your answers. Risk labels describe exposure created by missing workflows. They are not a prediction of your CMS final score or payment adjustment, which depends on performance relative to your cohort. Participation data is from the CMS final CY27 participant file. Requirements summarized from 42 CFR Part 512 Subpart G. Not legal, billing, or reimbursement advice.
Learn More
- CMS: Ambulatory Specialty ModelModel overview, timeline and participant information
- CMS: ASM Frequently Asked QuestionsAnswers to common participant questions
- CMS: ASM Model Fact SheetSummary of the model (PDF)
- CMS: ASM Participant ListSearch the final CY27 participant list on data.cms.gov